A research reference, not legal advice. Text is OCR of the Board's PDFs; the PDF is the authoritative record.

Document — 91-EB-ALD-010

Case
91-EB-ALD-010
PDF
Original PDF (8 pages)
Source
Board of Election Commissioners

Text reconstructed automatically from the OCR of the PDF; the PDF is the authoritative version.

Page 1

STATE OF ILLINOIS ) NBC ss. COUNTY OF COOK } ELECTORAL BOARD FOR THE HEARING AND PASSING UPON OF OBJECTIONS TO NOMINATING PETITIONS FOR THE OFFICES OF: MAYOR, CLERK AND TREASURER OF THE CITY OF CHICAGO; AND ALDERMAN IN THE CITY OF CHICAGO, FOR THE FEBRUARY 26, 1991 MUNICIPAL PRIMARY AND ALDERMANIC ELECTIONS. IN RE: Objection of: Michael P. Garza To the Nominating Petition of: Joseph Blackmon NO: 91-EB-ALD-~-10 Candidate for the Office of Alderman of the 10th Ward. fet ee ee Se Meet el ee? eel

DECISION

The duly constituted Electoral Board, consisting of MICHAEL

J. HAMBLET, ARNETTE R. HUBBARD and RAYMOND L. JAGIELSKI, or-

ganized by law in response to a Call issued by MICHAEL J. HAMBLET, Chairman of said Electoral Board, for the purpose of hearing and passing upon Objections to Nominating Petitions for the Offices of Mayor, Clerk and Treasurer of the City of Chicago and Alderman in the City of Chicago, having convened on December 28th, 1990 at 10:00 a.m. in the City Council Chambers, City Hall, Chicago, Illinois; and having heard and determined the objections to the petition in the above entitled matter find that:

1. The said Electoral Board has been legally constituted ac- cording to the laws of the State of Illinois;

2. Objections to the nominating petition of the candidate herein were duly filed;

3. A call to the hearing on said objections was duly issued and was served upon the members of the Electoral Board, the Ob- jector and the Candidate by mail and by personal service as provided by statute;

4, A public hearing was held on these objections commencing on December 28th, 1990;

Page 2

The following persons, among others, were present at such hearings: the members of the Electoral Board, the Objector by Counsel, and the Candidate and his Counsel; The Board finds that the Objector failed to present any case or cite any statute that requires invalidating a Candidate’s nominating papers solely because different forms of his name are used on his petition sheets and his Statement of Can- didacy. The Objector also failed to present any testimony or other evidence to establish that there was , in fact, any confusion in the minds of the voters as to the individual on whose behalf they were signing up the petitions. Moreover, pursuant to Lewis v. Dunne, 344 N.E.ed 443 (1976) and Madison v. Sims, 6 I11.App.3d 795, when read as a whole, the Candidate’s nominating papers are sufficient at law. IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that the objections of Michael P. Garza to the nominating petition of Joseph Blackmon, candidate for election to the office of Alderman of the 10th Ward, are hereby overruled and said petition is hereby declared valid and the name of Joseph Blackmon, candidate for election to the office of Al- derman of the 10th Ward, shall be printed on the ballot for the Aldermanic Election to be held on February 26th, 1991. Dated: Chicago, Illinois, this 20 aay of January, 1991. Netra.

MICHAEL J. LET, CHAIRMAN

Coat R. 7 Loa de Chapter 46 Section 10-5 Illinois Revised Statutes #10

Page 3

ATTACH TO PETITION

Business Records Code 613

STATEMENT OF CANDIDACY

NONPARTISAN

NAME | ADDRESS--ZIP CODE | OFFICE | CITY OR DISTRICT

BLACKMON, J | 2256 E. 96TH ST. 60617 | ALDERMAN | CHICAGO, ILL.

STATE OF ILLINOIS

County of COOK } ss.

I, JOSEPH BLACKMON , being first duly sworn (or affirmed), say that I reside at 2256 E. 96TH Street, in the CITY of CHICAGO Zip Code 60617 in the County of COOK , State of Illinois; that I am a qualified voter therein, that I am a candidate for ALDERMANIC (Nomination or Election) to the office of 10TH WARD ALDERMAN in the CITY OF CHICAGO (City, School, College or Special District) to be voted upon at the election to be held on the 26 day of FEBRUARY , 19 91 ; and that I am legally qualified to hold such office and that I have filed (or I will file before the close of the petition filing period) a Statement of Economic Interests as required by the Illinois Governmental Ethics Act and I hereby request that my name be printed upon the official ballot for 10TH WARD ALDERMAN to such office. (Nomination or Election) Signed and sworn to (or affirmed) by Joseph Blackmon (Signature of Candidate) this 13TH day of December , 19 92 .

"OFFICIAL SEAL"

ARTHUR J. PRZYBYLA

NOTARY PUBLIC, STATE OF ILLINOIS

My commission expires 10/16/91 Laura Pappalardo

NOTARY PUBLIC

Rev. 7/87 #10

Page 4

LEWIS v. DUNNE

Cite as 344 N.E.2d 443 III. 443 the fee charged plaintiff's children was not part of the price of, or payment for, instruction. For the reasons stated the judgment of the appellate court is affirmed. Judgment affirmed.

03 Ill.2d 48 Melvin B. LEWIS, Petitioner, v. Robert Jerome DUNNE et al., Respondents.

No. 48147.

Supreme Court of Illinois.

March 18, 1976.

Original proceeding was instituted on petition for writ of mandamus to compel electoral board to expunge its order sustaining objections to petitioner's nominating papers. The Supreme Court, Underwood, J., held that candidate for the office of judge of the Appellate Court, First Judicial District, substantially fulfilled statutory requirement that he set forth in his statement of candidacy "the office for which he is a candidate," notwithstanding his failure to specify the vacancy he was seeking in his statement of candidacy, where nominating papers, of which statement of candidacy was a part, clearly stated particular vacancy, and there was no conflict or inconsistency between description of office in petitions signed by electors and statement of candidacy. Writ awarded.

1. Courts 207.4(3) Although original proceeding in Supreme Court for writ of mandamus was concerned primarily with whether electoral board that entered an order sustaining objection to nominating papers of petitioner was properly constituted, where determination of that issue would still leave the underlying substantive question of the validity of petitioner's nominating papers to be resolved either in a hearing for a newly constituted electoral board or by a further hearing in the circuit court in the pending review of the board's decision, and neither course could be completed sufficiently in advance of primary election, the Supreme Court determined to review the electoral board's decision on the substantive question. S.H.A. ch. 46, §§ 7-10, 10-9, 10-10, 10-10.1.

2. Elections 141 Purpose of provision of Election Code prescribing form and content of nominating petitions for public office is to provide an orderly procedure whereby qualified person seeking public office may enter primary elections. S.H.A. ch. 46, § 7-10.

3. Elections 144 The nominating petition signed by electors and the statement of candidacy sworn to by the prospective candidate for public office are each intended to serve particular purposes and, while their sufficiency must be determined with reference to the particular function each was designed to accomplish, it was not intended that for all purposes they should be considered separate and apart as if the other did not exist. S.H.A. ch. 46, §§ 7-10, 10-9.

4. Judges 3 Candidate for the office of judge of the Appellate Court, First Judicial District, substantially fulfilled statutory requirement that he set forth in his statement of candidacy "the office for which he is a candidate," notwithstanding his failure to specify the vacancy he was seeking in his statement of candidacy, where nominating pa- Ae SS Oe ee ce Oe ere Sood we dds 444 Wl.

Page 5

pers, of which the statement of candidacy was a part, clearly stated particular vacan- cy, and there was no conflict or inconsist- ency between description of office in peti- tions signed by electors and statement of candidacy. S.ILA. cl. 46, $§ 7-10, 19-9, See publication Words and Phrases for other judicial constructions and definitions. .

5. Elections C144 Apparent purpose of requirement that a statement of candidacy be included as a part of candidate’s nominating papers is to obtain a sworn statement from candidate establishing his qualifications to enter pri- mary clection for office he seeks. S.Ill. ch. 46, §§ 7-10, 10-9.

ee Melvin B. Lewis, pro se.

Andrew M. Raucci, Chicago, for re- spondents.

UNDERWOOD, Justice:

On December 29, 1975, the Cook County ~ Officers Electoral Board entered an order sustaining certain objections to the nomi- Nating papers of petitioner, Melvin B. Lewis, who sought nomination in the March 16, 1976, primary election as the Democratic candidate for the office of judge of the Appellate Court, First Judicial District, to fill the vacancy created by the retirement of the Hlonorable Robert E. English, While review of that decision was pending in-the circuit court of Cook County (Ill.Rev.Stat.1973, ch. 46, par. 10- 10.1), petitioner was granted leave to file an original action in this court. On Janu- ary 19, 1976, after hearing oral argument and upon consideration of the papers here on file, we determined the petition should be treated as one for a writ of mandamus.

Considering the petition as such, we or- dered that a writ of mandamus issue com-

344 NORTH EASTERN REPORTER, 2d SERIES

manding the members of the Cook County Officers Electoral Board to expunge its order sustaining the objections to petition- er's nominating papers; to enter an or- der denying such objections; and to trans- mit to the State Board of Elections a certi- fied copy of its ruling in the manner pro- vided hy section 10-10 of the Election Code (Ill.Rev.Stat.1973, ch. 46, par. 10-10).

This opinion states the reasons for that or- der.

The nominating papers filed by petition- er with the State Board of Elections in- cluded petitions signed by Democratic Par- ty primary electors requesting that his name appear on the ballot for the office in question, and a statement of candidacy sworn to by petitioner in which he con- firmed various matters regarding his quali- fication for the office. The office for which the nominating papers were filed was described on the electors’ petitions as “Judge of the Appellate Court of Illinois, First Judicial District, to fill the vacancy created by the retirement of the Honorable Robert E. English." The statement of candidacy, however, described the office as “Judge of the Appellate Court of Illinois, First Judicial District” without indicating the particular vacancy. The basis for the objections filed by respondent Michael J. Cunningham was that section 7-10 of the Election Code (Ml.Rev.Stat.1973, ch. 46, par. 7-10) requires that the specific vacan- cy be designated in the statement of candi- dacy as well as in the petitions signed by electors, and that petitioner’s failure to do so rendered the nominating papers invalid.

{1] The matter was referred by the State Roard of Elections to the Cook County Officers Electoral Board, which is designated by section 10-9 of the Election Code (HLRev.Stat.t973, ch. 46, par. 10-9) as the body to hear and pass upon objec- lions to nominating petitions under these circumstances. By a 2-1 decision, the board denied petitioner’s motion to dismiss *

Page 6

LEWIS v. DUNNE III. 445

Cite as 314 N.E.2d 441 for want of jurisdiction and entered an or- adequately present a very narrow and der sustaining the objections to his nomi- clearly defined question of statutory con- nating papers. Although petitioner's suit struction as to which the pertinent facts in this court is concerned primarily with are not in dispute. Accordingly, in view whether the electoral board was properly of the desirability for prompt resolution of constituted, determination of that issue this matter, we decided the electoral alone would still leave the underlying sub- board's decision on the substantive question stantive question of the validity of peti- should be reviewed here. tioner's nominating papers to be resolved either in a hearing before a newly consti- Among the various provisions of section tuted electoral board or by a further hear- 7-10 of the Election Code prescribing the ing in the circuit court of Cook County in form and content of nominating petitions the pending review of the board's present for public office is the requirement that decision. It is evident neither course could "[t]he name of no candidate for nomina- be completed sufficiently in advance of the tion * * * shall be printed upon the primary election to allow petitioner a fair primary ballot unless a petition for nomi- opportunity to conduct a campaign, should nation has been filed in his behalf as pro- the substantive issue be decided in his fa- vided in this Article in substantially the vor. The materials on file in this court following form:

We, the undersigned, members of and affiliated with the ....... party and qualified primary electors of the ....... party, in the ....... of ......., in the county of ....... and State of Illinois, do hereby petition that the following named person or persons shall be a candidate or candidates of the ....... party for the nomination for * * * the office or offices hereinafter specified, to be voted for at the primary election to be held on the ..... day of ....... A.D. .....

Name | Office | Address John Jones | Governor | Belvidere, Ill. Thomas Smith | Attorney General | Oakland, Ill. Name ........................ Address ...................."

The prescribed form of petition also con- set out the address of such candidate, the tains a sworn certificate as to the genuine- office for which he is a candidate, shall ness of the signatures, party affiliation and state that the candidate is a qualified pri- correctness of residence of those signing mary voter of the party to which the peti- the petition. tion relates and is qualified for the office specified * * *, shall state that he has Section 7-10 further provides that filed a statement of economic interests as "[e]ach petition shall include as a part required by the Illinois Governmental Eth- thereof, a statement of candidacy for each ics Act, shall request that the candidate's of the candidates filing, or in whose behalf name be placed upon the official ballot, the petition is filed. This statement shall and shall be subscribed and sworn to by j i ' TST ae ee ee me ee tae ae,

Page 7

446 I. 344 NORTH EASTERN REPORTER, 2d SERIES

such candidate before some Officer authorized the State and shall be in Substantially the rized to take acknowledgment of deeds in following form: ‘ John Jones County of ...

Street in Address 102 Main St. Relvidere, lineis Statement of Candidacy District —_— Statewide Office ee Governor Republican ++, being first duly sworn, Say that I reside at... the city (or Village) of ..... in the county of eeeeene State of Illinois: that [ama qualified voter there- in and am a qualified Primary voter of the ....,,. party; that I am 2 Candidate for nomination * * « to the office of on et te et pes tereees to be voted upon_at the primary election be held af on the ......, day of 7 ..... A.D. ....; tat Taney qualified (including being the holder of any license that may be an eligibility requirement for the office [ seek the nomi- Nation for) to hold such office and that I have filed a state- ment of economic interests as required by the Minois Goy- ernmentat Ethics Act and [ hereby request that my name be printed upon the official Primary ballot for nomination for * « * such office.

Signed ..0..0.00 tee eeeeeee —_—<———— [2,3] The general purpose of Section each was designed to accomplish, it was 7-10 and related Provisions of the Election not intended that for all Purposes they Code is to Provide an orderly procedure should be considered separate and apart as whereby qualified persons Seeking public if the other did not exist. To the con- office may enter primary elections, The trary, section 7-10 provides that nominat- Petitions signed hy electors and the State- ing petitions shall include a statement of ment of candidacy sworn to by the pro- candidacy “as a part thereof.” spective candidate are each intended to Serve particular Purposes in this regard, [4] We do not agree with the electoral While their sufficiency m ust be determined board’s determination that petitioner's fail- with reference to the particular function ure to specify the vacancy in the statement Perera ctetentt tens oye

Page 8

CESSNA v. MONTGOMERY

Cite as 344 N.E.2d 447 III. 447 of candidacy rendered his nominating papers invalid. Those papers, of which the statement of candidacy was a part, clearly stated the particular vacancy. There was no conflict or inconsistency between the description of the office in the petitions signed by electors and the statement of candidacy, and in our opinion there was no basis for confusion as to the office for which the nominating papers were filed. The State Board of Elections and the Cook County Officers Electoral Board obviously had no difficulty in ascertaining that petitioner was seeking nomination for the office of judge of the Appellate Court, First Judicial District, to fill the vacancy created by the retirement of the Honorable Robert E. English.

[5] The apparent purpose of the requirement that a statement of candidacy be included as a part of a candidate's nominating papers is to obtain a sworn statement from the candidate establishing his qualifications to enter the primary election for the office he seeks. In this respect, we perceive no difference in the qualifications for "Judge of the Appellate Court, First Judicial District," and "Judge of the Appellate Court, First Judicial District, to fill the vacancy created by the retirement of the Honorable Robert E. English." In our judgment, petitioner substantially complied with the provisions of section 7-10 which require that the statement of candidacy set out "the office for which he is a candidate," and we hold that the decision of the Cook County Officers Electoral Board to the contrary was in error.

In view of the foregoing determinations, it is unnecessary to consider the questions raised by petitioner concerning the composition of the electoral board.

For these reasons, the writ of mandamus was awarded.

Writ awarded.

63 Ill.2d 71 Thelma L. CESSNA, Appellee, v. Raymond MONTGOMERY, Appellant.

Donna MALONE, Appellant, v. McCarthy DUNLAP, Appellee.

Nos. 47738 and 48002.

Supreme Court of Illinois.

March 18, 1976.

Actions were brought by mothers seeking to establish paternity of illegitimate children. One was dismissed by the Circuit Court, Lawrence County, Philip Benefiel, J., and the Appellate Court, Fifth District, reversed and remanded, 28 Ill.App.3d 887, 329 N.E.2d 861. The appeal was consolidated with one transferred from the Appellate Court, Fifth District, on appeal from the Circuit Court of Lawrence County, Irwin Cohen, J. The Supreme Court, Underwood, J., held that the two-year limitation upon the institution of paternity suits is valid, but that a putative father may be estopped from asserting it.

One case reversed and remanded, the other vacated and remanded.

1. Constitutional Law ⇔308 Test of whether substantive due process was violated by statute, imposing time limitation for establishing paternity was whether statute was reasonable after evaluating competing interests; it was necessary to ask what legitimate state interests were promoted by the statute, and what fundamental personal rights might be endangered by it. S.H.A. ch. 106¾, §§ 52, 54.

2. Action ⇔63 State has legitimate interest in preventing litigation of stale or fraudulent claims. S.H.A. ch. 106¾, § 54.