Decision — 08-EB-RGA-031
- Case
- 08-EB-RGA-031
- Original PDF (37 pages)
- Source
- Board of Election Commissioners
- Hearing officer
- Casandra Watson
- Attorneys named
- Michael J. Kasper
Text reconstructed automatically from the OCR of the PDF; the PDF is the authoritative version.
Page 1
FINDINGS AND DECISION
The duly constituted Electoral Board, consisting of Chicago Board of Election Commissioners Langdon D. Neal, Richard A. Cowen and Marisel A. Hernandez, organized by law in response to a Call issued by Langdon D. Neal, Chairman of said Electoral Board, for the purpose of hearing and passing upon objections ("Objections") of KRISTOPHER J. ANDERSON ("Objector") to the nomination papers (“Nomination Papers”) of DERRICK PRINCE, candidate for nomination of the Democratic Party to the office of Representative in the General Assembly for the 32nd District, State of Illinois ("Candidate"), having convened on November 20, 2007, at 10:00 am., at 69 W. Washington Street, 8" Floor Conference Room, Chicago, Illinois, and having heard and determined the Objections to the Nomination Papers in the above-entitled matter, finds that:
l. Objections to the Nomination Papers of the Candidate herein were duly and timely filed.
Page 2
2. The said Electoral Board has been legally constituted according to the laws of the State of Illinois.
3. A Call to the hearing on said Objections was duly issued by the Chairman of the Electoral Board and served upon the members of the Electoral Board, the Objector and the Candidate, by registered or certified mail and by Sheriff's service, as provided by Statute.
4. A public hearing held on these Objections commenced on November 20, 2007 and was continued from time to time.
5. The Electoral Board assigned this matter to Hearing Examiner Casandra Watson for further hearings and proceedings.
6. The Objector and the Candidate were directed by the Electoral Board to appear before the Hearing Examiner for a hearing on the date and at the time designated on the Electoral Board’s docket. The following persons, among others, were present at such hearing: the Objector, KRISTOPHER J. ANDERSON, appearing by counsel, Michael J. Kasper; and the Candidate, DERRICK PRINCE, appearing pro se.
7. The Candidate filed a motion to stnke the Objector’s Petition, arguing that it was a “shot gun” objection not based upon a reasonable investigation of facts.
8. The Hearing Examiner ordered that an examination of the registration records be conducted by clerks and agents under the Board's direction and supervision, in accordance with the laws of Illinois and the rules of the Board.
9. The Hearing Examiner directed all parties to appear and be present, either personally and/or by their authorized representatives during the records examination.
Page 3
10. The Candidate or his duly authorized representative(s) was present during the examination of the registration records.
11. The Objector or his duly authorized representative(s) was present during the examination of the registration records.
12. The examination of the registration records was completed and the Electoral Board hereby adopts and incorporates by reference the results of the records examination conducted by its clerks and agents. The written report of the results of the registration records examination is contained in the Electoral Board's file in this case and is available for inspection upon request of a party.
13. ‘The results of the records examination conducted in this matter indicate that:
A. The minimum number of valid signatures required by law for placement on the ballot for the office in question is 500; B. The number of purportedly valid signatures appearing on the nominating petition filed by the Candidate total 2,356;
C. The number of signatures deemed invalid because of objections sustained total 1,820:
D. The remaining number of signatures deemed valid total 536. i4. — Following completion of the records examination, the Hearing Examiner denied the Candidate’s motion to strike and dismiss the Objector’s Petition, finding that the Candidate’s motion was without merit inasmuch as a review of the records examination indicate that approximately seventy-seven percent (77%) of the Objections were sustained during the records examination.
Page 4
15. Both parties filed Rule 8 statements seeking to present evidence. The Hearing Examiner conducted a series of evidentiary hearings. After considering all of the evidence and argument from both sides, the Hearing Examiner concluded that the Candidate’s nominating petition sheets contain only 488 valid signatures, short of the 500 minimum signatures required by law.
16. The Hearing Examiner has tendered to the Electoral Board her report and recommended decision. The Hearing Examiner recommends that the Objections to the Candidate’s Nomination Papers be sustained and that the Nomination Papers be found invalid.
17. The Electoral Board, having reviewed the record of proceedings in this matter and having considered the report and recommendations of the Hearing Examiner, as well as all argument and evidence submitted by the parties, hereby adopts the Hearing Examiner’s recommended findings and conclusions of law. A copy of the Hearing Examiner’s Report and Recommended Decision is attached hereto and is incorporated herein as part of the decision of the Electoral Board.
18. The Electoral Board finds that the objections to signatures listed on certain sheets and lines of the Objector's Petition are sustained in part and overruled in part as more fully mdicated in the results of the records examination.
19. The Electoral Board finds that the number of valid signatures appearing on the Candidate's nominating petition is fewer than the minimum number of valid signatures required by law to be placed upon the official ballot as a candidate for nomination of the Democratic Party to the office of Representative in the General Assembly for the 32nd District, State of Illinois.
Page 5
<0. For the reasons stated above, the Electoral Board sustains the Objections to the Candidate’s Nomination Papers and finds that the Candidate’s Nomination Papers are invalid.
I!’ IS THEREFORE ORDERED that the Objections of KRISTOPHER J. ANDERSON to the Nomination Papers of DERRICK PRINCE, candidate for nomination of the Democratic Party to the office of Representative in the General Assembly for the 32nd Representative District, State of Illinois, are hereby SUSTAINED and said Nomination Papers are hereby declared INVALID and the name of DERRICK PRINCE, candidate for nomination of the Democratic Party to the office of Representative in the General Assembly for the 32nd Representative District, State of Uhnois, SHALL NOT be printed on the official ballot for the General Primary Election to be held on February 5, 2008.
Dated: Chicago, Illinois, this 16th day of December, 2007. LK yy od a f Richard A-~Cowen, Commissioner ~ , orice] ATE rnandez, AC PUTUSSLONCT NOTICE: Pursuant to Section 10-10.1 of the Election Code (10 ILCS 5/10-10.1) a party aggrieved of this decision and seeking judicial review of this decision must file a petition for judicial review with the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Cook County within 10 days after the decision of the Electoral Board. s
Page 6
BEFORE THE DULY CONSTITUTED ELECTORAL BOARD FOR THE
HEARING AND PASSING UPON OF OBJECTIONS TO NOMINATION
PAPERS OF CANDIDATES FOR NOMINATION TO THE OFFICE OF
REPRESENTATIVE IN THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY FOR THE 33RD
REPRESENTATIVE DISTRICT OF THE STATE OF ILLINOIS
KRISTOPHER J. ANDERSON, }
} - Petitioner-Objector, ) eS
) 08-EB-RGA-31 =
v. )} > ) on
DERRICK PRINCE, ) 5
, ) Respondent-Candidate, ) “T cr
HEARING EXAMINER’S RECOMMENDED DECISION = ™
This matter appearing on call for the first time on November 20,2007 at 1:00 P.M.; the Petitioner-Objector being represented by Atty. Michae] Kasper (Atty, Raucoj appearing) and the Respondent-Candidate appearing pro se; the Respondent- Candidate filing his Motion to Strike and Dismiss instanter. At the request of counsel for the petitioner-objector a review of the Motion to Strike and Dismiss was completed by this hearing examiner and a records examination was ordered and scheduled at that time. This matter was continued to November 27, 2007 at 1:00 P.M. for hearing on all Motions to Strike and Dismiss timely filed. Thereafter the following pleadings were timely filed:
1. Petitioner-Objector’s Response to the Motion to Strike and Dismiss 2. Respondent-Candidate’s Response to Motion to Strike and Dismiss On November 27, 2007 this matter appeared on call for the second time for hearing on all motions commencing at 1:35 P.M. Respondent-Candidate appearing Pro se and Atty, Michael Kasper appearing on behalf of the Petitioner-Objector. The records examination ordered on November 20, 2007 had not been completed and the parties proceeded to hearing on Respondent-Candidate’s Motion to Strike and Dismiss. After argument by both parties this matter was continued to November 30, 2007 for the results of the record examination. No decision was rendered on the record re: Motion to Strike and Dismi | On November 30, 2007, this matter appeared on call for the third time, commencing at 1:05 P.M. Atty. Kasper appeared on behalf of the objector and Derrick Prince appeared pro se. The records examination having been completed on November 28, 2007, the following results were spread of record:
-|- 08-EB-RGA-31
Page 7
Number of Signature on Petitions: 2, 356 Number of Objections overruled: 260 Number of Objections sustained: 1,820 Number of Valid Signatures: 536 Minimum Signature Requirement: 500 Upon inquiry by this hearing examiner, Atty. Kasper indicated that he intended to file a Rule 8 Motion no later than Monday, December 3, 2007. Thereafter this matter was set at the convenience of Derrick Prince for Tuesday, December 4, 2007 at 2:00 P.M.
RECOMMENDED DECISION RE: MOTION TO STRIKE AND DISMISS
Candidate’s Motion to Strike and Dismiss is without merit. A review of the records examination indicates that approximately seventy-seven percent (77%) of the objector’s objections were sustained. MOTION DENIED On Monday, December 3, 2007 Atty. Kasper filed his Rule 8 Statement and accompanying six (6) pages. On December 4, 2007, at 1:41 P.M. (19 minutes b/4 the hearing on Rule § motions had been previously scheduled, Derrick Prince filed his Candidate's Rule 8 Statement and accompanying sixteen (16) pages. Additionally, both parties made formal requests te produce board records. (Mr. Prince’s request was made during the hearing at 3:45 P.M. on December 4, 2007.
On December 4, 2007 at 2:30 P.M. this matter appeared on call for the fourth time for hearing on Mr. Kasper’s Rule 8 Motion. Atty. Kasper appeared on behalf of the objector and Derrick Prince appeared pro se. Total Valid Signatures prior to the commencement of the Rule 8 Motion was 536.
Atty. Kasper advised that his Rule $ evidence would be divided into three (3) categories; (1) mathematical errors; (2) objections made but not ruled upon during the records examination, and (3) objections overruled during the records exam. Thereafter the following evidence was adduced by Atty. Kasper:
CATEGORY ONE
MATHEMATICAL ERRORS
Nominating Petition Sheet 423 - 14 signatures on page. Board Form 148-pp. 23 indicating 15 signatures on page in Column 2. Valid signatures should be one (1) not two (2).
FINDING: Total valid signatures reduced from 536 to 535,
-2- 08-EB-RGA-31
Page 8
Board Worksheet 436-Line 5—the S in Column C not carried over to Column E. end Line 7--the S in Colemnu C was not carried over to Column E, resulting in neither being included in the total) sustained.
FINDINGS: Total valid signatures reduced from 535 to 533. Board Worksheet #52-Line 15--the S in Column C not carried over to Column E and therefore not being included in the total sustained. FINDINGS: Total valid signatures reduced from $33 to 532. Nominating Petition #78--14 signatures on pg. 78 not 15 as recorded on Form 148 and Board Worksbeet--resulting in (0) valid signatures ow page #78. FINDINGS: Total valid signatures reduced from 532 to 531. Nominating Petition #86--14 signatures on pg. 86 not 15 as recorded on Form 148 and Board Worksheet. (0) valid on pg. 86 FINDINGS: Total valid signatures reduced from $31 to 530. Board Worksheet #94-Line 7-Column A objections sustained-not carried over to Column E and therefore not included in total sustained; should be 14 sustained not 13 sustained; one (1) valid not two (2).
FINDINGS: Total valid signatures of 530 reduced to 529.
Board Worksheet #96-Line 14 and Lime 15-Column C sustained but not carried | over to Column E and Column A sustained not carried over to column E and therefore neither were included in total number sustained. Total sustained should be 13 not 11, valid should be 2 not 4.
FINDINGS: Total valid signatures of $29 reduced to §27.
~3- 08-EB-RGA-31
Page 9
Board Worksheet #100-Line 15-Column C sustained not carried over to Column E, not included in total sustained. Total sustained should be twelve (12) not eleven (11).
FINDINGS: Total valid signatures of 527 reduced to 526.
Board Worksheet #103-Line 14-sustained in Column C not carried over to Column E and not included in total sustained. Total sustained is eight (8) not seven (7), valid seven (7) not eight (8).
FINDINGS: Total valid signatures of 526 reduced to 525.
Board Worksheet #105-Line 13-sustained in Column A not carried over to Column E and not included in total sustained. Total sustained should be twelve (12) not eleven (11).
FINDINGS: Total valid signatures of 525 reduced to 524.
Board Worksheet #106-Line 10, sustained in Column A not carried over to Column E and not included in total sustained. Total sustained should be eight (8) not seven (7).
FINDINGS: Total valid signatures of 524 reduced to 523.
Board Worksheet #107-Line 15, sustained in Column A not carried over to Column E and not included in total sustained. Total sustained should be eight (8) not seven (7).
FINDINGS: Total valid signatures of 523 reduced to 522.
Board Worksheet #109-Line 15, sustained in Column C not carried over to Column E and not included in total sustained. Total sustained should be nine (9). Total Valid should be six (6) not seven (7).
FINDINGS: Total valid signatures of 522 reduced to 521.
-4- 08-EB-RGA-31
Page 10
Board Worksheet #112-Line 15, sustained in Column A not carried ever to Column E and not included in total sustained. Total sustained should be fourteen (14) not thirteen (13). Total valid should be one (1) not two (2). FINDINGS: Total valid signatures of $21 reduced to $20.
CATEGORY TWO
OBJECTIONS MADE BUT NOT RULED UPON AT RECORDS EXAM
Board Worksheet #2-Line 11-Column A objection “signer not registered...” no ruling during records exam. Objector’s Exhibit #2 tendered which is a certification from the Bd. Of Elections with a list of every person registered at 10226 S. Yates. FINDINGS: No ruling on objection 1] A-signer not registered at address shown. Objection sustained. Total sustained should be eleven (11) not (10), overruled two (2) not three (3). Total valid signatures of 520 reduced to $19. Recapitulation Sheet #2-Line 12-Column C objection. Board Worksheet #2-Line 12, Worksheet has NO OBJECTION at 12C. Objection is clear on objector’s recap sheet pg. 2 line 12C-“signer resides outside of district”. Objector Exhibit #3-registration record of signer-which indicated that the address for signer is NOT in the 33™ Representative District.
FINDINGS: Objection Sustained. Total valid signatures of 519 reduced to 518. nt renege ppp pane Recapitulation Sheet #2-line 15-Column C objection. No ruling during records exam. Nominating Petition #2-Line 15-Park Forest address listed for signer. FINDINGS: Objection Sustained. No previous ruling made, Administrative notice taken that Park Forest, Illinois is not within the 33 Representative District. Total valid signatures of 518 reduced to 517.
Recapitulation Sheet #41-line 14(c) “signer resides outside of district” objection noted. Board Worksheet pg. 41 at line 14C- no ruling entered during records exam. Objector’s Exhibit #4-registration for Gerand French, 614 E. 95" Street offered. Address is not in 33% Representative District.
FINDINGS: Objection Sustained. No previous ruling made during records exam. Total valid signatures reduced from 517 to 516.
-5- 08-EB-RGA-31
Page 11
Recapitulation Sheet #44-Line 14C, "signer resides outside of district" objection noted. Board Worksheet pg. 44 on Line 14C, no ruling entered during records exam.
Objector's Exhibit #5-jurisdiction look-up certified by Bd. Of Elections tendered. Nominating Petition Sheet #44-line 14, address is 7245 East End.
FINDINGS: 7245 East End is address on pg 44 at line 14 on nominating petition sheet. This address is not in the 33rd Representative District according to jurisdiction look-up. Objection Sustained. Total valid signatures of 516 reduced to 515.
Nominating sheet 44-Line 15-address is 8223 S. East End. Recap. Sheet #44-Line 15A objection noted, "signer not registered at address shown". Board Worksheet Pg. 44-Line 15 contains no ruling under Column A. Objector's Exhibit #6-list of all registered voters at 8223 South East End. No one named James Haywood is registered at 8223 S. East End.
FINDINGS: Objection Sustained. Total valid signatures of 515 reduced to 514.
******** NOTE ********
****See nominating petition sheets 28-33, 93-115 and 165-166 on which circulator is
JAMES HAYWOOD-SIGNATURE IS THE SAME AS SIGNATURE ON sheet 44
Line 15--shown residing at 47 Timberlane Rd, Matteson, Illinois.
Recapitulation Sheet #90-Line 15C, "signer resides outside of district". Board Worksheet-no objection entered or ruled upon on Line 15C, sheet 90.
Objector's #7-registration record of Marva Evans at 11014 S. Vernon-not located in 33rd Representative District.
FINDINGS: Objection Sustained, signer resides outside of district. Total valid signatures reduced from 514 to 513.
Recapitulation Sheet 99-Line 1A, "signer not registered at address shown". Nominating Petition sheet 99, Line 1 contains the name of Eric Gray, 9244 South Ogresby.
Objector's Exhibit #8-Board Certification from Lance Gough, stating in pertinent
-6- 08-EB-RGA-31
Page 12
Recapitulation sheet #1 14-line 14C,“signer resides outside of district” NOT transferred to Board Worksheet pg. 114. Nominating Petition Sheet 114, Line 14 address is 14537 Clinton, Harvey, Illinois.
FINDINGS: Administrative Notice taken, 14537 Clinton, Harvey, Illinois is Not within the 33% Representative District. Total valid signatures reduced from 508 to 507.
Recapitulation sheet #114-line 15C, “signer resides outside of district” NOT transferred to Board Worksheet pg. 114.
Objector’s Exhibit #16-registration record for 1204 West 97* Place, NOT located within 33 Representstive District.
FINDINGS: Objection Sustained. Total valid signatures reduced from 506 to 505. {taken out of sequence by objector) Recapitulation sheet #119, tine 10C, “signer resides outside of district”? NOT transferred to Board Worksheet #115.
Objector’s Exhibit 14-registration for 9337 S. Woodlawn, Board Certification indicates that address is NOT within 33™ Representative District. FINDINGS: Objection sustained, Total valid signatures reduced from 507 to 506.
CATEGORY THREE
OBJECTIONS OVERRULED AT BOARD EXAM
Recapitulation sheet#17, line 6C, “signer resides outside of district”. Nominating Petition Sheet 17, line 6’s address is 1025 East 93™ St. Objection overruled at exam. Objector’s Exhibit 17-registration for 1025 East 93 St. NOT within 33" Representative District. Name on petition matches name on registration card. FINDINGS: Objection sustained. Total valid signatures reduced from 505 to 504. Recapitulation sheet #37, Line 4A, “signer not registered at address shown”. Overruled by Board during exam.
Objector’s Group Exhibit #18-list of all registrants at 9230 South Colfax. 8- 08-EB-RGA-3i part that “9244 South Oglesby is not 2 valid address in the City of Chicago and there are no registered voters at 9244 South Oglesby.
Page 13
FINDINGS: Objection sustained. Total valid signatures reduced from 513 to 512. Recapitulation sheet #99-Line 2A objection, “signer not registered at address shown”. Board Worksheet Peg. 99 at Line 2A, no objection recorded or ruled upon during records exam Objector’s Exhibit #9 tendered-printout of all of the registered voters at 9311 South Luella. No person named Gordon registered at 9311 S. Luella. FINDINGS: Objection Sustained. Total valid signatures reduced from 512 to §11. Recapitulation sheet 99, Line 3A objection, “signer uot registered at the address shown”. Board Worksheet Pg. 99, Line 3A, no objection recorded or ruled upon during records cxam.
Objector’s Exhibit #10 tendered-Certification by Lance Gough that 9327 South Luelis has no registered voters.
FINDINGS: Objection Sustained. Total valid signatures reduced from 511 to 510. Recapitulation sheet 110, Linel5C objection, “signer does not reside in the district” was not transferred to Board Worksheet.
Objector’s Exhibit #11 and Objector’s Exhibit #12 list every person registered at 8804 South Buriey and 8804 South Buriey is not in the 33% Representative District. FINDINGS: Objection sustained. Total valid signatures reduced from 510 to 509. Recapitulation sheet 114 Line 13C, “signer does not reside in the district” was not transferred to Board Worksheet pg. 114-line13C.
Objector’s Exhibit #13-registration record of Jerome Hereford, registered at 6546 South Orkley. This address is not in the 33° Representative District. FINDINGS: Objection sustained. Total valid signatures reduced from 509 to 508.
-7- 08-EB-RGA-3]
Page 14
FINDINGS: Objection sustained. More probable than not that Kimberly did NOT sign petition sheet. Total valid signatures reduced from 504 to 503, Recapitulation sheet #41, Line 9B, “signers signature not genuine”. Overruled at Board exam. (not by Hayes) Objector’s Group Exhibit #19-certification of every registered voter at the address Of 1551 East 93 St. No registration or signature card for signer on Nominating Petition Sheet #41 Line 9.
FINDINGS: Objection sustained. Total valid signatures reduced from 503 to 592. Recapitulation sheet #43, Line 2A, “signer not registered at address shown”, Overruled at board exam.
Objector’s Exhibit #8 (previously tendered) Certification by Lance Gough, “there Is NO address 10145 Seuth Yete, as listed on Nominating Petition Sheet 43, Line 2. FINDINGS: Objection sustained. Total valid signatures reduced from $02 to $01. Recapitulation sheet #54, line 6A, “signer not registered at address shown” and 6D, “signer’s address missing or incomplete”. Both overruled at board exam. Objector’s Group Exhibit #20 and Objector’s Exhibit #8-Certification of every registered voter at 7611 S. Merrill.
FINDINGS: Objection sustained. Total valid signatures reduced from $01 to 500. Recapitulation sheet #58, line 13A, “signer not registered at address shown”. Overruled by board during exam.
Objector’s Group Exhibit #2]-lsting of all registrations for 9534 S. Clyde as well as All signature cards of registrants. Address on Nominating Petition sheet #58, line 13 is $534 S. Clyde.
FINDINGS: Objection sustained. No signature of any registrant registered at 9534 S. Clyde matches signature on Nominating Petition Sheet 58, line 13. Total valid signatures reduced from 508 te 499, ,
~9 08-EB-RGA-31
Page 15
Nominating Petition Sheet 56, line 11, signers last name is Watkins, address: 10152 S. Oglesby. Overruled by board during exam.
Objector’s Group Exhibit #22-listing of all registrants at 10152 S. Oglesby-no on Named Q or T Watkins registered at 10152 S. Oglesby.
FINDINGS: Objection sustained. Total valid signatures reduced from 499 to 498. Recapitulation sheet #68, line LA, “signer not registered at address shown”, Overruled by board during exam. Nominating sheet #68, line 1 address is 9510 ———_—.
Objector’s Exhibit #24-Certification from Lance Gouph- three (3) people named Paul Booker registered in City of Chicago-none live at 9510, on any street in Chicago.
FINDINGS: Objection sustained. Total valid signatures reduced from 498 to 497. Recapitulation Sheet #74, Line LA, “signer not registered at address shown” and 1D, “address missing or incomplete”. Overruled by board at exam. Objector’s Exhibit #25-complete registration records for all registrants at 9018 S. Crandon or 9018 S. Creiger. (CR being the first two letters of the address on Nominating petition sheet 74 line 1.)
FINDINGS: Objection sustained-person who signed is not registered at either address beginning with CR. Total valid signatures reduced from 497 to 496, Recapitulation Sheet #75, line 6A, “signer not registered at address shown”, and “signer’s address missing or incomplete” at 6D; overruled by board during exam.
Objector’s Exhibit #26-Certification of all registered voters at 7122 S. Constance. FINDINGS: Objection sustained. Signer of nominating petition sheet 75, line 6 is pot registered. Total valid signatures reduced from 496 to 495, Recapitulation Sheet #81, line 4B, “signer’s signature not genuine”-overruled by Board during exam.
~10- 038-EB-RGA-31
Page 16
Objector’s Exhibit 427-Registration record of all registrants at 8906 S. Crandon. FINDINGS: Objection Overrnied-no change in valid signatures, still 495. Recapitulstion sheet #90, line 10A, “signer not registered at address shown”. Overruled by board during exam.
Objector’s Exhibit 428-registration record for Cynithia Boone canceled. FINDINGS: Objection sustained. Registration czuncelled. Signer not registered. Total valid signatures changed from 495 to 494.
Recapitulation sheet #98, line 4A, “signer not registered at address shown”. Overruled by board during exam.
Obijector’s Exhibit #29-registration card.
FINDINGS: Objection overruled-po change in valid signatures, still 494. Recapitulation sheet #99, line 5A and 5B, “signer not registered at address shown” and “signcr’s signature not genuine”. Overruled by board during exam. Objector’s Exhibit #30-registrations for all parties registered at address on Nominating Petition sheet 99, line 5.
FINDINGS: No match with any of the registered voters. Objection sustained. Total valid reduced from 494 to 493.
Recapitulation sheet #109, line 13A and 13C, “signer not registered at address shown” and “signer resides outside of district”, both overruled Curing records czar.
Objector’s Exhibit 3-listing of all registered voters at 8719 South Exchange-address is NOT within 33” Representative District.
FINDINGS: Objection sustained. Address is not within 33% Representative District. Total valid signatures reduced from 493 to 492.
-11- 08-EB-RGA-3}
Page 17
Recapitulation Sheet #114, Line 7B, “signer’s signature not genuine”. Overruled during records exam.
Objector’s Exhibit 32-all registrations fro 11814 S, Sangamon. No signature resembling Kimberly Kennerman’s -and no one named Kimberly Kinnerman registered, FINDINGS: Objection sustamed. No one named Kimberly Kinnerman registered at 11814 S. Sangamon and no signature of any registered voter matches signature on nominating petition sheet 114 at liac 7. Total valid signatures reduced from 492 to 491.
Recapitulation Sheet #116 Line 6A and B, “signer not registered and no genuine signature.
Objector’s Exhibit #33-registrations of all voters at 9629 S. Brennan with last name Of Townsend.
FINDINGS: Three Townsends registered at 9629 S. Brennan. No first name on nominating petition sheet 116, line 6. Objection sustained. Total valid reduced from 491 to 490.
Recapitulation sheet 119, line 9A, “signer not registered at address shown”. Nominating petition sheet 119 at line 9 has address of 2575 E. 98™ St. Objector’s Exhibit 34-certification from Lance Gough indicating that there are ne registered voters at 2575 East 98° Street.
FINDINGS: Objection sustained. No registered voters at 2575 E. 98" St. Total valid reduced from 490 to 489.
Recapitulation sheet 123, line 9A, B, C and D, “signer not registered...”, “signer’s signature not genuine...”, “signer resides outaide of district”, “siener’s address missing...”. Address on nominating petition sheet 123, line 8-9187 S. Phillips.
Objector’s Exhibit 34-certification from Lance Gough saying in pertinent part that Address of 9187 S. Phillips does not exist.
FINDINGS: Objection sustained. Total reduction from 489 to 488.
~“12- 08-EB-RGA-3}
Page 18
Mr. Kasper moved to suspend his presentation in light of the fact that Mr. Priace Was now down to 488 valid signatures, indicating that any further evidence would be cumulative if Mr. Prince could not recovery the necessary 12 signatures, This hearing examiner agreed to suspend evidence in the Rule 8 presentation per Mir. Kasper’s request and to begin with Mr. Prince’s Rule 8 Motion at this time.
DERRICK PRINCE’S RULE 8 EVIDENCE
TOTAL VALID SIGNATURES-488
Recapitulation sheet #8, line 11A and B, “signer not registered...” and “signer’s signature pot pennine...”.
Candidate’s Exhibit #1-registration card for Sherry Cook. FINDINGS: Already overruled and counted on behalf of candidate. No addition to total valid signatures of 488.
Nominating Petition Sheet 8, line 12, Julius Brown is signer-sustained by handwriting expert.
Candidate’s #2-registration card FINDINGS: No addition-sustained by expert. Concur with expert. Total valid signatures remains 488.
Nominating Petition Sheet 12, Line 1-sustained as not signed in own proper person by handwriting expert.
Candidate’s #3-registration card for Marie Harris.
FINDINGS: Concur with expert. No addition. Total remains 488 valid signatures. Nominating Petition Sheet 13, line 2-Charics Frost 9021 S. Essex-sustained by expert as not genuine.
Candidate’s #4-registration card for Charles Frost.
-13- 08-EB-RGA-31
Page 19
FINDINGS: Concur with expert. No change in total valid signatures, still 488. Nominating Petition Sheet #15, tine 16. Duane Hampton, 2506 E. 95* Pl. sustained on registration.
Line 15-9 on Rule 8 Motion has Thomas Hayes. Atty. Kasper objected to amendment of Rule 8 motion.
FINDINGS: Objection sustained, no amendment allowed on Rule 8 motion. No change to total signatures valid, still 488.
Nominating Petition Sheet pe. 18 line 12. Barbara Collins-8216 S. Dobson-sustained by expert as to genuineness of signature.
Candidate’s #5-Registration card.
FINDINGS: Concur with expert, no change in total valid signatures, still 488. Nominating Petition Sheet #22, line S-Sondra M. Golden-8011 S. Artesian, sustained in exam-address not in district.
Key book check by this hearing examiner, verifies that address is not in 33™ Representative District.
FINDINGS: 8011 S. Artesian is not in the 33% Representative District. No change to total signatures valid, still 488.
Nominating Petition Sheet #23, line 4, Larry Bird, 8728 S. Dante. Candidate’s 7-Registration card for Larry Bird Grimes.
FINDINGS: Name on registration does not match name on petition sheet. No change. Total valid signatures remains 488.
Nominating Petition Sheet #23, line 13-sustained as signer not registered at address shown during ¢xsm.
-i4- 08-EB-RGA-31 Candidate's Exhibit #8-Registration for Feliciz Broughton. FINDINGS: Angela Davis is name on nominating petition, sheet 23, line 13 not Felicia Broughtoa-no addition. MR. PRINCE WITHDRAWS EXHIBIT. Nominating Petition Sheet 23, line 14, Nate Washup-9124 S. Avalou-sustained by Expert-not penuine.
Page 20
Candidate’s Exhibit #@-Registration for Nate Washup.
FINDINGS: Concur with expert. No addition. Total valid signatures-488 Nominating Petition Sheet 40, line 6-objection overruled at exam. FINDINGS: No change. Already credited 25 overruled in favor of candidate. Total valid signatures-488.
Nominating Petition Sheet 43, line 3-Devise Brown, 76° Blackstone-sustained for Incomplete address during exam.
FINDINGS: Address incomplete on face of nominating petition sheet 43, line 3. Total valid signatures remains 488.
Nominating Petition Sheet 43, line 11-sustained on genuineness by expert. Candidate’s Exhibit #9-Registration card.
FINDINGS: Concur with expert. No change. Total valid signatures remains 488. Nominating Petition Sheet 44, line 1, Randall Davis-9635 Jeffery-sustained on address not in district at exam.
Rule 8 Motion docs not contain Randal! Davis on Sheet 44-Line 1. Objection to Amendment of Rule 8 by Atty. Kasper. Objection granted.
FINDINGS: Amendment to Rule 8 motion denied. No change. Total valid signatures remains at 488.
~1$- 68-EB-RGA-3]
Page 21
Nominating Petition Sheet 45 line 4-Debra Campbell-10129 S. Hoxie-sustained on not registered at address shown during exam.
Candidate's Exhibit #418-Registration for Debra Campbell, 10130 S. Hoxie. FINDINGS: Objection sustained-no change- total valid signatures remains 488. Nominating Petition Sheet 45, line 12-George Murry-sustained by expert, not genuine.
Candidate’s Exhibit 11-Registration of George Murry.
FINDINGS: Concur with expert. No change. Total valid signatures remains 488. Nominating Petition Sheet 52, line 9-Mary Thomas-10451 S. Bentley-sustained as not genuine by expert during exam.
Candidate’s Exhibit #12-Registration for Mary Thomas.
FINDINGS: Concur with expert. No change. Total valid signatures remains 438. Nominating Petition Sheet #52 line 12-Boyce Davis-22.49----____, sustained as not Genuine by expert during exam.
Candidate’s Exhibit t3-Registration for Boyce Davis-2249 $100* St. FINDINGS: Concur with expert. Nu change. Total valid signatures remains 488. Nominating Petition Sheet 57, line 3, ? , sustained by Expert as not genuine during exam.
Candidate's Exhibit #14-Registration Card.
FINDING: No change. Concur with Expert. Total valid signatures remains 488. Nominating Petition Sheet 45 line 4, sustained by expert as not signed on own proper person.
-16- 08-EB-RGA-31
Page 22
Nominating Petition Sheet 45, line 4-sustained a3 to genuine signature by expert during exam.
Candidate's Exhibit #13-Registration for Ahmed Ho-9822 South Bensley. FINDINGS: Concur with expert. No change. Total valid signatures still 488. Nominating Petition Sheet 55, line 13, Letha Cunningham-ustsined as to genuine Signature by expert during exam.
Candidate’s #16-Registration card.
FINDINGS: Concur with expert. No change. Total valid signatures still 488. Nominating Petitien Sheet $8, Line 3-Marilyn Regulus-9337 S. Paxton-sustained as to genuine signature by expert during exam.
Candidate’s #17-RKeputration card.
FINDINGS: Concur with expert. No change. Tota} valid signatures stil} 488. Nominating Petition Sheet 58, line 6-Aubry Brant.
FINDING: Already overruled and credited to candidate. No change, stil] 488. Nominating Petition Sheet 59 line 1-LaDonna Lowe-2222 East 99® St. sustained as not genuine by expert during exam.
Candidate’s Exhibit #18-Registration card.
FINDINGS: Concur with expert. No change. Valid signatures remains 488. Nominating Petition Sheet 59, line 4-Veronica Champion-9324 S. Cornell-sustained By expert as pot genuine during exam.
Candidate’s Exhibit #19-Registration card.
FINDINGS: Concur with expert. Total valid signatures remains 488.
17- 08-EB-RGA-31
Page 23
Nominating Petition Sheet 59, ine 5-Marie Bonds-sustained by expert as not genuine during exam.
Candidate's Exhibit #20-Registration card.
FINDINGS: Concur with expert. No change. Total valid signatures remains 488. Nominating Petition Sheet #62, line 5-Tahisha Whitaker-sustained by expert as not genuine during exams.
Candidate's Exhibit #21-Registration card.
FINDINGS: Concur with expert. No change. Total valid signatures remains 488. Nominating Petition Sheet 24, line 4-April Cooper-sustained by expert as not genuine-3764 South Ingleside.
FINDINGS: Not ia District and concur with expert. No change. Total valid-488. Nominating Petition Sheet 24, line 3-sustained not in district. Name on nominating Petition is Tre Marshall. Rule § motion has name of Jamie Jones at sheet 24, line 3. FINDINGS: Line 3 is not on Rule 8 Motion-No change. Total valid-488. Nominating Petition sheet 59, line 4-sustsined as not genuine by expert. Candidate's Exhibit #19-Registration card.
FINDINGS: Concur with expert No change. Total valid signatures remains 488. (taken out of turn-returned when signature card available) Nominating Petition Sheet 68, line 10-sustained as not genuine by expert. Candidate's Exhibit 23-Recapitulation Sheet #68-at candidate’s request for evidence.
FINDING: Concer with expert. No change. Valid signatures remsins 488. This matter was concluded at 12:15 A.M. and continued to 9:00 A. M.
- 18. 08-EB-RGA-31
Page 24
On December 5, 2007 at 9:00 A.M. this matter appeared on call for the Fifth time continued from 12:15 A.M. this morning for a continuation of Mr. Derrick Prince’s Rule 8 Motion. Atty. Kasper was represented by Atty. Liu and Mr. Derrick Prince appeared pro se. Total valid signatures at this time remains at 488.
Nominating Petition Sheet 105, line i-sustained by expert as not genuine. Norma Coleman is name on nominating petition.
Candidate’s Exhibit #25-Registration card.
FINDINGS: Concur with expert. No change. Total valid signatures remains 488. Nominating Petition Sheet 197, line 7, Charles Botchey-sustained by expert as not genuine.
Candidate’s Group Exhibit #26-Registration card.
FINDINGS: Concur with expert. No change. Total valid signatures remains 488. Nominating Petition Sheet 109, line 9-sustained as not registered at address shown. Candidate's Exhibit #27-Registration card for - Aguilera FINDINGS: Registration card tendered does not contain address shown on sheet _ 109, line 9 and Rule 8 Motion does not show name on Nominating Petition Sheet 109 Line 9. No change. Motion to Strike Exhibit #27 granted as irrelevant. station ppgremneemiiinan Nominating Petition Sheet 110, line 2-Wayne?????-sustained as nor registered at address shown. Rule & motion has 118 fine 2 for Jerrie Norman and that is not the name listed on the nominating petition sheet 110, line 2. FINDINGS: No change-nominating petition sheet and Rule 8 Motion for sheet 110, line 2 are 2 completely different names. Total valid signatures remain 488. Motion To Strike granted by Kasper.
a igor eerererenavntashsirprenratm tng Nominating Petition Sheet 112, line 1-sustained as not genuine by expert. Candidate’s Exhibit #28-Registration card.
FINDINGS: Concur with expert. Valid signatures remain 488
-19- 08-EB-RGA-31
Page 25
Nominating Petition Sheet 121, line 4, sustained as not genuine by expert. Candidate’s Exhibit #29-Registration card for Freida A. McLendon Rule 8 Motion has Z. McLendon. Motion to Strike Granted FINDINGS: Concur with expert. Ne change. Valid signatures remain 488. Nominating Petition Sheet 113, line 12-Alvin Logan on Rule 8 Motion-sustained by expert as not genuine.
Candidate’s Group Exhibit#}#-Registration card for Lagan. FINDING: Concur with expert. No change. Valid signatures remain 488. Objection by Candidate Nominating Petition Sheet #114, line 1, sustained as not genuine by expert. Candidate’s Group Exhibit #31-Registration and signature file for Inga Angelet Fortson.
FINDING: Concur with expert. No change. Valid signatures remain 488. Objection by Candidate.
Nominating Petition Sheet 115, line 5-sustained as not genuine by expert. Anite Bialef is on Rule 8 Motion sheet 115, line § Candidate’s Exhibit WITHDRAWN FINDING: No change. Valid signatures remain 488.
Nominating Petition Sheet 115, line 6-Steve Liddell on Rule 8 Motion-sustained on Severs! including address not in district.
FINDING: Address at Sheet 115, line 6 is in Blue Island, and not in 33° Representative District. No change. Valid signatures remain 488. Nominating Petition Sheet 116, line 9-Rale 8 Motion shows a L. Miller, sustained as Not genuine by expert. — Candidate's Exhibit 432. Registration Card.
FINDING: Concur with expert. No addition. Valid signatures remain 488. Objection by Candidate.
-20)- 08-EB-RGA-31
Page 26
Nominating Petition Sheet 116, line 13, Rule 8 Motion has TER Smith-9627 S. Jeffery, sustained as signer not registered at address shown. Candidate’s Exhibit #33-Registration card for Theodore Smith-9627 S. Jeffery. FINDING: Name on registration card and name on nominating petition sheet different. No change. Valid signatures remain 488 (Exhibit Withdrawn by Candidate) Nominating Petition Sheet 117, Line 10. Rule § Motion for 117, line 16 is Rochelle Williams. Sustained by expert as not genuine.
Candidate’s Group Exhibit #33-Voter Registration file for Rochelle Williams. FINDING: Concur with expert. No change. Valid signatures remain st 488. Objection by Candidate.
Nominating Petition Sheet 119, line 2. Role 8 Motion at 119 line 2 is Mary Akia Grant, 9749 South Jeffery. Sustained by expert as not genuine. Nominating Petition Sheet 119, tine 2 is not Makia Grant--Rule 8 Motion has Wrong line number, should be lie 1 and not line 2.
FINDING: Objection sustained by Mr. Kasper re: Rule 8 Motion and accompanying evidence. No change. Valid signatures remsia 488. Nominating Petition Sheet 120, Line 2. Rule 8 Motion has Christine Gayden, 19707 S. Yates at 120 Line 2. Sustained by expert as not genuine. Candidate's Group Exhibit #34-Voter Registration FINDINGS: Concur with expert. No change. Objection by Candidate. Nominating Petition Sheet 124, Line 5. Rule 8 Motion has Smith David, 8246 S. Yates at 124, line §. Sustained as not genuine by expert. Candidate's Exhibit 435-Voter Registration FINDINGS: Concur with expert. Objection by Candidate. Valid still 483
21- 08-EB-RGA-31
Page 27
Nominating Petition Sheet 124, fine 11. Rule 8 Motion for 124, 11b, Billy McClelland, 7944 S. Chapelle. Sustained by expert as not genuine. Candidate’s Exhibit #36: Voter Registration Card FINDINGS: Concur with expert. No change. Objection by Candidate. Nominating Petition Sheet 127, line 6. Rule 8 Motion pg. 126 line 6b, Stephanie Minter, 3051 S. Manistee. Sustained by expert es not genuine. Candidate’s Exhibit #37-Voter Registration FINDINGS: Concur with expert. No change. Objection by Candidate. Nominating Pctitien Sheet 129, line 5. Rule 8 Motion bas Joanne Parks, 10242 Cathoun. Sustained by expert as not genuine.
Candidate’s Exhibit #38-Registration for Joanne Parks.
FINDINGS: Concur with expert. No change. Objection by Candidate. Nominating Petition Sheet 130, line 1A.
FINDINGS: Already overruled in favor of candidate. No change. Still 483 Nominating Petition Sheet 131, line 12. Rule 8 Motion at 131, line 12, Jimmie Baker, 9721 S. Merrill. Sustained as not genuine-Striken and overruled by Expert.
FINDINGS: Credit already given to candidate. No change. Still 488 valid sipnatures.
Nominating Petition Sheet 131, tine 12, sustained by expert as not genuine. Rule 8 Motion at 131, line 13b, Gregory Baker, 9721 S. Merrill.
Candidate's Exhibit#39-Voter Registration for Gregory A. Baker, 9721 S. Merrill. FINDINGS: Concur with expert. No change. Objection by Candidate.
~22- 08-EB-RGA-31
Page 28
Nominating Petition Sheet 131, line 14, sustained by expert as not genuine. Rule 8 Motion 131, 14b, bas Eddie Baker, $721 S. Merrill.
Candidate’s Exhibit #46-Voiter Registration FINDINGS: Concur with expert. No change, still 488 valid signatures. Candidate Objection.
Nominating Petition Sheet 140, line 6. Rule 8 Motion 140, line 6b, Cynthia Turner, 2157 E. 96" St, sustained as not genuine by expert.
Candidate’s Exhibit #41-Voter Registration for Cindy Turner at 2157 E. 96* St. FINDING: Concur with expert. No change, still 488 valid signatures. Candidate Objection.
Nominating Petition Sheet 136, Line 13. Rule 8 Motion 136, line 138. Sherice Perkins, 9938 Caiboun.
FINDING: Already overruled. No change.
Nominating Petition Sheet 134, Line 8b, Audrey Goins, 16336 South Crandon. Sustained as not genuine by expert.
Candidate's Exhibit #42-Voter Registration for Audrey Goins. FINDING: Concur with expert. No change. Objection by Candidate. Valid 488. Nominating Petition sheet 141, line S$. Rule § Motion for 141 line 5B, Ricky Brown, 2200 E. 97" St. Sustained by expert as not genuine.
Candidate’s Exhibit 43-Ricky Brown, 2200 E. 97" St. FINDING: Concur with expert. No change. Objection by Candidate. Valid 488. Nominating Petition Sheet 141, Line 6b, Cherilyn Health-9002 S. Kingston-sustained as not genuine by expert.
Candidate’s Exhibit #44-Voter Registration for Cherilyn Health at same address.
-23. 08-EB-RGA-31
Page 29
FINDING: Concur with expert. No change. Objection by Candidate Nomination Petition Sheet 142, line 4. Rule 8 Motion, 142, line 4b, Jesse Harley 9661 Crandon. Sustained as not genuine by expert. Candidate's Group Exhibit #45-Voter Registration of Jesse Harley-9661 S. Crandon. FINDING: Concur with expert. No Change. Objection by Candidate. Nominating Petition Sheet 143, Line 6. Rule 8 Motion 143, 6b, Joseph Stanton 9037 S. Paxton. Sustained by expert as not genuine. Candidate's Exhibit #46-Voter Registration for Joseph Stanton at 9037 S. Paxton. FINDING: Concur with expert. No change. Objection by Candidate. Rule 8 Motion Sheet 143, line 7b, Arena Moore, 9941 S. Benaley. Records exam Sustained at 143, line 7b as not genuine by expert. Candidate's Exhibit #47-Voter Registration for Arena Moore. FINDING: Concur with expert. No change. Objection by Candidate. Rule 8 Motion at 146, line 6b, Anna B. Smith, 2650 E. 93rd St. Sustained during Exam by expert as not genuine. Candidate's Exhibit #48-Voter Registration for Annabelle Smith, 2650 E. 93rd St. FINDING: Concur with expert. No change. Objection by Candidate. Valid 468. Rule 8 Motion, pg 75, line7b, Eleus Whitney, 8616 South Jeffery. Sustained as not genuine by expert. Candidate's Exhibit #49-Voter Registration Eleus Whitney, 8616 South Jeffery
-24- 08-EB-RGA-31
Page 30
FINDING: Concur with expert. No change, still 488 valid signatures. Candidate Objection.
Rule 8 Motion, pg. 78, line 14b, Tiffany Hudson, 2659 E. 92nd St. Sustained as not Genuine by expert.
Candidate's Exhibit #50-Registration Record for Tiffany Hudson, 1025 North Drake. Objection to Exhibit-nonprobative by Mr. Kasper because address is Different.
FINDINGS: Objection sustained, address different from Rule 8 Motion-relevancy. Concur with expert. EXHIBIT WITHDRAWN.
Rule 8 Motion, Pg. 80, line 1, Jerry Gates, 2641 E. 93rd St. Sustained as not registered at address shown. Nominating Petition sheet 80, line 1 does not have Jerry Gates.
FINDINGS: No evidence, no change. Valid signatures remains 488.
Rule 8 Motion pg. 81, line 9a, J. Locket, 8836 S. Crandon-sustained as signer not Registered at address shown.
FINDINGS: No evidence. No change. Objection by Candidate.
Rule 8 Motion Pg. 88, line 2a-Tommy Scott, 10009 Calhoun. Sustained as not registered at address shown.
FINDINGS: No evidence. No change.
Rule 8 Motion pg. 88 line 15a-Regina Matthews, 9326 S. Colfax. Sustained as signer Not registered at address shown.
FINDINGS: No evidence. No change.
Rule 8 Motion sheet 89, line 1A, Roshaun Marshall, 2219 E. 97th St. Sustained as Signer not registered at address shown.
FINDINGS: No evidence, No change.
-25- 08-EB-RGA-31
Page 31
Rule 8 Motion Sheet 89, Line 8-Curtis Johnston, 2346 E. 96" St. sustained as signer Not registered at address shown.
FINDINGS: No evidence, no change.
Rule 8 Motion sheet 89, line 9c, Andre Hooks, 10543 §. Vates. Sustained as not registered at address shown.
FINDINGS: No evidence, no change.
Page 24, line 4, sustained as to signature and district.
FINDINGS: WITHDRAWN BY CANDIDATE
Rule § Motion pg. 83, line 14, Tamiko Nezh, sustained as not genuine by expert. Candidate’s Exhibit #50-Voter Registration for 2226 W. 80° St. for Tamilo Neah. FINDING: Concur with expert. Objection by Candidate, Valid still 488. Rule 8 Motion pg. 84, line 9 is Christine Cutwright, 9349 S. Chapelle. Sustained by Expert as not genuine.
Candidate’s Exhibit #51-Voter Registration for Christine Cutwright-9349 S. Chappelle.
FINDING: Concur with expert. Objection by Candidate. Valid still 488. No change.
Rule 8 Motion pg. 85, line 14-Guadalope Reyes, 11258 Grembay. Sustained as Not genuine by expert.
Candidate’s Exhibit #52-Voter registration for Guadalupe Reyes. FINDING: Concur with expert. Objection by Candidate. No change, still 488.
~26- 08-EB-RGA-31
Page 32
Rule 8 Motion pg. 85, line 12-Terry Sipp. Sustained as not genuine by expert.
Candidate's Exhibit #52-Voter Registration for Terry Sipp-9676 S. Luella.
FINDING: Concur with expert. No Change. Objection by Candidate.
Rule 8 Motion pg. 86, line 2-N.R. Scott. Sustained as not genuine by expert.
Candidate's Exhibit # 54-Registration for Regina Nicolle Scott at 7400 S. Constance.
FINDING: Concur with expert. Objection by Candidate. No change.
Rule 8 Motion pg. 91, line 8, Lawrence Thompson, 9621 Luella. Sustained as not Genuine by expert.
Candidate's Exhibit #55-Voter registration for Lawrence Thompson, 9621 Luella.
FINDING: Concur with expert. Objection by Candidate.
Rule 8 Motion pg. 93 line 5 is Charlie Powell, 2657 E. 93rd St. Sustained by expert as Not genuine.
Candidate's Exhibit #56-Charlie Powell. 2657 East 93rd St. FINDING: Concur with expert. No change. Objection by Candidate.
Rule 8 Motion pg. 93 line 6-sustained as not genuine.
Candidate's Exhibit#57-Voter Registration.
FINDING: Concur with expert. No change. Objection by Candidate.
Rule 8 Motion pg. 93 line 7, Erika Powell. Sustained as not genuine by expert.
Candidate's Exhibit #58-Voter Registration for Erika Powell.
FINDING: Concur with expert. No change. Objection by Candidate.
-27- 08-EB-RGA-31
Page 33
Rule 8 Motion pg. 93 line 8. Sustained as not genuine by expert. Juanita Williams. Candidate's Group Exhibit #59-Voter Registration for Juanita Williams. FINDING: Concur with expert. No change. Objection by Candidate. Rule 8 Motion pg. 93 line 12, Emma Brook. Sustained as not genuine by expert. Candidate's Group Exhibit #60-Voter search results for Emma L. Brook. FINDING: Exhibit irrelevant. Motion to Strike Exhibit Granted. No change. Candidate Objection.
Rule 8 Motion pg. 94-line 4-sustained as not genuine by expert. Candidate's Exhibit #61-Voter registration for Evelyn Garcia. FINDING: Concur with expert. No change. Objection by candidate. Rule 8 Motion, pg. 93 line 13-B. Bahamon. Sustained by expert as not genuine. Candidate's Exhibit #62-Voter Registration file for B. Bahamon-2537 E. 97th St. FINDING: Concur with expert. No change. Objection by candidate. Rule 8 Motion, pg. 93, line 14. Joyce Brumfield. Sustained as not being genuine by expert. Candidates Exhibit #63-Signature file from Board for Joyce Brumfield. FINDING: Concur with expert, no change. Candidate Objection. Rule 8 Motion, pg. 102, line 1-Eanlia Ewing. Sustained as signer not registered at Address shown. Candidate's Exhibit #64-Voter Registration for Erika-#57049FF
-28- 08-EB-RCA-31
Page 34
FINDING: Name on Rule 8 Motion does not match Candidate’s Exhibit. No Change, candidate objection.
Rule 8 Motion pg. 146, line 7, Wanda McDuffett. Sustained by expert as not genuine.
Candidate’s Exhibit #65-Voter Registration for Wanda McDuffy at 2600 E. 93™ St. FINDING: Concur with expert, no change. Candidate Objection. Rule 8 Motion pg. 94 line 6-MecChittmi. Sustained as not genuine by expert. Candidate's Exhibit #66-Voter Registration-non-admissible on issue of genuineness Of signature.
FINDING: Candidate’s Exhibit #66-no admissibic on issue of genuine signature. Candidate Objection.
Rule $ Motion Pg. 83, line 2-Barbara Sheila, 2723 E. 93™ St. Sustained as signer Not registered at address shown.
Candidste’s Exhibit #67-Voter registration for Barbara Cheeks at 2723 E, 93” St. FINDING: Exhibit #67 name does not match Rule 8 motion. Exhibit no admissible, Nonuprobative .. Objection by Candidate. No change. Valid signature total still 488. By stipulation of the parties, the following names and addresses are entered as Group Exhibit#68-from pp. 9 of Candidate’s Rule 8 Motion. The objection was the same for each, Le. signer not registered at address shown. The parties agree that the name that appears on the petition DOES NOT appear on the record entered for that particular name.
Candidate contends that the record is incomplete; objector contends that record is complete:
PAGE NO: L NO: NAME OF SIGNER
$2 4 Yvette Thompson 81 lls B. Mecinley $1 13 M. Callaway 81 14 C. Coleman | iS J. Buckley
29. 08-EB-RGA-31
Page 35
PAGE NO: | LINE NO: | NAME:
82 | 1 | NO NAME ON RULE 8
82 | 2 | Blare Kemp 86 | 13 | Cindy Young 87 | 1 | Cleo Grehora 82 | 5 | Gwnedoloyn Brite 83 | 3 | Regina Mason 83 | 11 | ? Adams 83 | 12 | Michael Ferguson (stricken by candidate) 83 | 13 | George Ferguson 84 | 4 | Laura Hudson 84 | 10 | Erika Hanley 84 | 15 | Lisa Studstill 85 | 2 | Sheretha Reberee 85 | 5 | Vanessa Hunter 85 | 6 | Aaron Hunter 85 | 7 | Wilma Jackson 85 | 8 | Gary Walker 85 | 9 | Keith Hadley 85 | 10 | Viola Day 85 | 13 | (no name on Rule 8) 86 | 3 | Lena Johnson 86 | 5 | Maria Navarro 86 | 6 | Daniel Mayo 86 | 7 | Felicia Luefvon 86 | 8 | (no name on Rule 8) 86 | 10 | J. Blackburn 86 | 11 | Tracy Martin This concludes Group Exhibit #68 entered by agreement of the parties. The Group Exhibit consists of a group of voter registration records that lists the entire listing of Registered voters at each particular address.
Candidate's position: Documents are missing or incomplete. Objector's position: Documents complete, signers not registered at address shown.
GROUP EXHIBIT #69
Same group of exhibits as heretofore entered, except they relate to pg. 10 of candidate's Rule 8 Motion.
-30- 08-EB-RGA-31
Page 36
FAGE NO: LINE NO: | NAME:
93 9 Shanita Williams 93 10 Kayla Williams 87 13 Diana Powell 90 7 Benjamin Andrews SI § Yolanda Gregory 9] 9 Eric Matthews 91 12 (no name on Rule 8) 92 5 Rachelle McLin 92 14 Rian Ceda $3 3 Anthony L. Thomas 94 7 Denise or Deniere Johnson 94 13 Maria Caluak This concludes Exhibit #69 and by agreement of the parties is entered jato evidence. Objector contends that documents do not prove that signer is registered at address shown.
Candidate contends that documents are incomplete and missing voter registration files that board did not provide.
Candidate Exhibit #70-entered by agreement.
FINDINGS: Regarding board documents included in Group Exhibit #68, I find that None of the documents entered prove that any of the signers were registered at the addresses shown on the corresponding nominating petition sheets. I further find that regarding Candidate’s Exhibit #69, none of the documents catered prove that any of the signers were registered at the addresses shown on the Corresponding nominating petition sheets.
I further find that candidate’s Exhibit 70 fails to prove that signer is registered at address shown.
ALL EVIDENCE HAVING BEEN CONCLUDED AND THERE BEING NOT
ADDITION TO CANDIDATES VALID SIGNATURES, VALID SIGNATURES
ARE STILL 488.
~%]- 08-EB-RGA-3]
Page 37
RECOMMENDED DECISION
The name of DERRICK PRINCE, not appear on the ballet for the office of Representative for the 33 Representative District, State of Ilineis on February &, 2608.
Respectfully submitted:
yy Casandra B. Watson, Hearing Examiner December 15, 2007