Hearing officer's report — 23-EB-ALD-032
- Case
- 23-EB-ALD-032
- Original PDF (14 pages)
- Source
- Board of Election Commissioners
- Hearing officer
- Yamil E. Colon
- Attorneys named
- Michael J. Kasper
Text reconstructed automatically from the OCR of the PDF; the PDF is the authoritative version.
Page 1
FINDINGS AND DECISION
The duly constituted Electoral Board, consisting of the Board of Election Commissioners for the City of Chicago, Commissioners Marisel A. Hernandez, William J. Kresse and June A. Brown, organized by law in response to a Call issued by Marisel A. Hernandez, Chair of said Electoral Board, for the purpose of hearing and passing upon objections ("Objections") of ROBERT L JACKSON and LAURENCE OLIVIER ("Objectors") to the nomination papers ("Nomination Papers") of DON DAVIS,for the office of Alderperson of the 3rd Ward ("Candidate") at the Municipal General and Alderperson Elections to be held on Tuesday, February 28, 2023, having convened on Friday, December 9, 2022 at 4:00 p.m. and having heard and determined the Objections to the Nomination Papers in the above-entitled matter, finds that:
1. Objections to the Nomination Papers of the Candidate were duly and timely filed.
2. The Electoral Board was legally constituted under the laws of the State of Illinois.
3. A Call to the hearing on said Objections was duly issued by the Chair of the Electoral Board and served upon the members of the Electoral Board, the Objectors and the Candidate, by registered or certified mail and by Sheriffs service, as provided by statute or service was waived.
Page 2
4. A public hearing held on these Objections commenced on Friday, December 9, 2022 and was continued from time to time. The Electoral Board assigned this matter to Hearing Officer Yamil E. Colon for further hearings and proceedings.
5. The Objectors and the Candidate were directed by the Electoral Board to appear before the Hearing Officer on the date and at the time designated in the Hearing Schedule. The following persons, among others, were present at such hearing: The Objectors, ROBERT L JACKSON and LAURENCE OLIVIER, through their attorney, MICHAEL J KASPER; and the Candidate, DON DAVIS.
6. The Hearing Officer ordered that an examination of the voter registration records be conducted by clerks and agents under the Board's direction and supervision, in accordance with the laws of Illinois and the rules of the Board.
7. The Hearing Officer directed all parties to appear and be present, either personally and/or by their authorized representatives, during this records examination.
8. The Candidate and/or his duly authorized representative was present during the examination of the registration records.
9. The Objectors and/or their duly authorized representative was present during the examination of the registration records.
10. The examination of the registration records was completed and the Electoral Board hereby adopts and incorporates by reference the results of the records examination conducted by its clerks and agents. The written report of the result of the registration records examination is contained in the Electoral Board’s file in this case and a copy has been provided or made available to the parties.
Page 3
11. The results of the records examination indicate that:
A. The minimum number of valid signatures required by law for placement on the ballot for the office in question is 473;
B. The number of purportedly valid signatures appearing on the nominating petition filed by the Candidate total 1361;
C. The remaining number of signatures deemed valid as a result of the records examination total 540.
12. The Hearing Officer conducted a hearing to allow the Objector an opportunity to present evidence in support of his Rule 8 motion objecting to the Board’s clerk’s findings during the records examination and in support of his other objections.
13. The Hearing Officer found that 8 sheets containing 80 signatures evidenced a pattern of fraud and false swearing and the Hearing Officer found that all such sheets should be stricken.
14. | The Hearing Officer has tendered to the Electoral Board a report and recommended decision. Based upon the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer found that the Candidate’s Nomination Papers contained only 460 valid signatures, which is less than the minimum number of valid signatures required by law to be placed upon the official ballot as a candidate for the office of Alderperson for the 3rd Ward, and that the Candidate’s Nomination Papers should be found invalid.
15. The Electoral Board, having considered the evidence and arguments tendered by the parties and the Hearing Officer’s report of recommended findings and conclusions of law, hereby adopts and incorporates the Hearing Officer's recommended findings and conclusions of law.
Page 4
16. For the reasons stated above, the Electoral Board finds that the Candidate has an insufficient number of valid signatures on his nominating petitions and that the Nomination Papers of DON DAVIS are, therefore, invalid.
IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that the Objections of ROBERT L JACKSON and LAURENCE OLIVIER to the Nomination Papers of DON DAVIS, candidate for election to the office of Alderperson of the 3rd Ward, are hereby SUSTAINED and said Nomination Papers are hereby declared INVALID and the name of DON DAVIS, candidate for the office of Alderperson for the 3rd Ward, SHALL NOT be printed on the official ballot for the Municipal General and Alderperson Elections to be held on Tuesday, F^l Dated: Chicago, Illinois, on Friday, January 13, 20 William U Kresse, Commissioner une A. Brown. Commissioner NOTICE: Pursuant to Section 10-10.1 of the Election Code (10 ILCS 5/10-10.1) a party aggrieved of this decision and seeking judicial review of this decision must file a petition for judicial review with the Clerk of the Circuit Court of Cook County within 5 days after service of the decision of the Electoral Board.
Page 5
23-EB-ALD-032 HO RECOMMENDATION.pdf - 01/03/2023 1:04 pm
BEFORE THE BOARD OF ELECTION COMMISSIONER OF THE CITY OF
CHICAGO AS THE DULY CONSITUTED ELECTORAL BOARD.
ROBERT L. JACKSON )
and SAMUEL LOWE, ) ) Petitioner-Objectors, ) )
V. ) NO. 23 EB-ALD-032
)
DON DAVIS, )
) Respondent- Candidate. )
HEARING OFFICER'S REPORT AND FINAL RECOMMENDATION
This matter came to be heard initially on December 12,2022. The Objectors, Robert L. Jackson and Samuel Lowe,appeared by counsel, Mr. Michael Kasper. The Candidate, Mr. Don Davis, appeared personally and stated that he was going to represent himself. Pro Se.
ISSUES RAISED BY OBJECTOR^S PETITION
In their petition, the Objectors raised issues regarding the Candidates nomination papers, including: voters whose address were incomplete or not shown on petitions; non- genuine signatures of registered voter; voters residing outside of district; missing or incomplete address of signer; and repeat voter signatures.
The most notable of objection was contained in paragraph 10 of Objectors' Petition. It alleged that a certain number of petition sheets circulated by a Mr. Kevin Hobby,contained signatures that were forged. It was further alleged that many signatures appeared to be signed by the same person, and therefore demonstrated a pattern of fraud and false swearing by the circulator. Although circulator Hobby had circulated 43 sheets for the Candidate, Objectors specifically targeted 7 sheets referred to in paragraph 10 of their objection. These were sheets: 23, 34,119,123,127,128 and 129.
The Hearing Officer issued a Record Examination Directive to be conducted on December 13,2022, and a status date for December 19,2022. No dispositive motions were filed by either side.
FACTS.FINDINGS AND ARGUMENTS
On December 16, 2022,the Objectors filed a Request for Subpoenas for 21 individuals identified in the request. There being no objection to this subpoena request by the Candidate,the Hearing Officer issued a recommendation that the subpoenas were relevant and necessary to support the issues raised in the Objectors' Petition.
Page 6
23-EB-ALD-032 HO RECOMMENDATION.pdf - 01/03/2023 1:04 pm By the December 19, 2022 status hearing date,the record examination had not yet been finalized. Only a preliminary Petition Summarj'Report was published by the Electoral Board. At this status hearing the Candidate, relying on this preliminary report, began by announcing that the case should be ended at this point. Wai\ang a copy of the preliminary report, the Candidate declared that he was already found to be 79 signatures above the minimum number of valid voters. Therefore, he argued to this Hearing Officer that it was not necessaiy to continue any further on this "fishing expedition". The Hearing Officer informed the Pro Se Candidate, that it was premature for him to claim victory at this early stage. The Hearing Officer then proceeded to explain to the Candidate, much to his disappointment, that the process was only half way done. The entire process was explained to him in summary'fashion, and the reasons why it was conducted this way were also explained. The Candidate seemed to absorb this information and slowly began to settle acquiescingly into his chair.
Following this explanatory discussion,the Objectors* counsel informed that he would be calling a Forensic Document Examiner for the actual hearing date, and that he would share details at a later time. The case was then continued to December 27,2022 for hearing on the merits of the Objectors* Petition. The following day after this hearing, on December 20, 2022,the final Petition Summary Report was released by Electoral Board personnel. It showed the Candidate with as total of540 valid signatures,67 more than the necessarj^ 473 valid signatures for the office of Alderperson.
One day prior to the December 27,2022 final hearing, counsel for the Objectors directed an email to the Board, Candidate and Hearing Officer. In it, Mr. Kasper indicated that he had not yet received the allowed subpoenas for issuance to his witnesses. He stated that the Board was closed during the weekend due to severe inclement weather, and he requested an extension oftime for issuance of the subpoenas. In addition, he announced his intention to call Mr. Warren Spencer as his forensic document examiner at the scheduled hearing. He attached a copy of Mr. Spencer's curriculum vitae. Mr. Kasper also related in his December 26, 2022 email, that Mr. Spencer had been traveling and was only able to confirm his appearance "a short time ago". He added that Mr. Spencer could only be available on December 27,2022 via Zoom.
Furthermore, Mr. Kasper stated that Mr. Spencer's testimony would bear directly on the allegations contained in paragraph 10 of his Objection. Particularly, the alleged false circulation and swearing by Kevin Hobby.
Page 7
23-EB-ALD-032 HO RECOMMENDATION.pdf - 01/03/2023 1:04 pm In the early morning of December 27, 2022,the Candidate issued an email response to Mr. Kasper's. He expressed opposition to an expert witness. The Candidate contended that Mr. Spencer was not a part of the subpoenas that Mr. Kasper "had issued to the Board", and that therefore his deadline for more subpoenas had passed and that this witness should not be introduced at an evidentiary hearing.
The Candidate argued,that since Mr. Kasper alleged a pastern offraud by Ke\an Hobby in the circulation of 7 sheets; and that since Kasper asserted in his email that Hobby circulated more than 40 pages; the Candidate imputed to Kasper an admission that the remaining vast majority of Hobby circulated sheets were signed in good faith. This was the sum and substance of the Candidates' opposition to Mr. Kasper's email. The Hearing Officer was not persuaded by the Candidate's elastic logic, and overruled his objection. On that same morning of December 27,2022,the Hearing Officer emailed both parties a reply. He informed them that the delay in the subpoenas was out of the control of Mr. Kasper, because of the extreme weather conditions causing the closing of the Board offices, and delaying his request. Rule 19 ofthe Electoral Board Rules and Procedures requires Board approval before issuing subpoenas.
The Hearing Officer informed the parties that because it had been disclosed the previous week that a witness such as Mr. Spencer would be called by the Objectors; and because the uncertaint>' of availability of Mr. Spencer caused the delay in confirming his appearance; and because notice of identity and credentials w^as made within a reasonable time, the Candidate's objection was overruled. The Candidate received a copy of the witness credentials and only objected that he wasn't on the delayed subpoena list. The Hearing Officer concluded his email response by informing all, that the matter would proceed with witness Warren Spencer via Zoom on the afternoon of December 27, 2022. Additionally, it was announced,that the presentation of subpoenaed witnesses would be held in abeyance pending the approval of the subpoenas by the Board. After some technical delay in connecting with Mr. Spencer, the hearing began with Mr. Kasper eliciting testimony aimed at qualifying the witness. Followed by the Candidate's questions related to Spencer's qualifications. No Candidate questions disputed the qualification of the witness and the hearing was commenced.
On direct examination, Mr. Spenser described the methodology used in examining handwriting on documents. He testified that signatures are unique to each individual and 23-EB-ALD-032 HO RECOMMENDATION.pdf - 01/03/2023 1:04 pm that these signatures are constructed by each individual with the shapes they form with the letters. He said that the focus is placed on the signer's construction of the letters in his/her signature.
Page 8
Mr. Spencer's attention was then drawn to the 7 sheets listed in paragraph 10 of the Objector's Petition, beginning with sheet 23. He w^as asked about his observations of the signature on line 3 of sheet 23. The name was "Edwina Da\is". Mr. Spencer described the capital "D" of Davis,as being unique in construction and difficult to copy. The witness' attention then turned to sheet 119, line 3 and line 5. Line 3 contained the name and the alleged signature of"Donna Burrell. Line 5 contained the name and alleged signature of"Martina Daniel". Reviewing these signatures, Mr. Spencer observed that the "D" construction of Edwina Da\is, contained the same common likeness formation as those D's contained in "Donna" and "Daniel". He concluded that they were wTitten by the same person.
Mr. Spencer was able to identify the same script of the letter "D"in the following locations and names:
Sheet 126, Line 5"Davis"(Sheet 126, not listed in paragraph 10 but w^as discovered while fanning through the petitions sheets;)
Sheet 127, Line 6"Darrius"; Sheet 127, Line 9 "Darrell";
Sheet 128,line 4"Davis"; Sheet 128, line 7"Diaz";
Mr. Spencer also found Common letter likeness construction with the letter "B". Sheet 128, Line 5"Beverly" & Line 6"Brenda";
Sheet 129, Line 6 show^ed common likeness structure with "D"for"De Angelo". Sheet 34(See Attached) was very revealing, in that it contained consecutive signatures, lines 1-5 which shared common likeness structure in forming letters "E","B","F", and "M". All five ofthese signatures were found to be authored by the same person. Similarly, there were signatures on sheets 128(See Attached) and sheet 34,that shared the same likeness structure, and found to be signed by the same person.
Mr. Spencer did not offer any testimony, nor W'-as any elicited from him regarding any of the other 36 sheets circulated by Kevin Hobby. After Mr. Spencer's direct examination ended,the Candidate was allowed to cross-examine.
The witness was asked by the Candidate whether he had ever made any mistake in his examination ofsignatures, and how many. Spencer admitted he has made mistakes, as anyone might. No additional questions of consequence were propounded on the witness. 23-EB-ALD-032 HO RECOMMENDATION.pdf - 01/03/2023 1:04 pm During his closing argument,the Candidate stated that the signatures found to be forgeries by the witness were the result of human error. Whereupon the Hearing Officer asked for clarification of this statement. He asked the Candidate whether he was arguing that all the alleged forged signatures on his petitions were placed there because of some human error? The Candidate did not offer any reasonable reply, and so the matter proceeded to closing arguments and conclusion.
Page 9
The forensic document examiner's testimony was credible, detailed and confident in his findings. Moreover, his testimony was unrebutted and unimpeachable. He stated that all seven of the petition sheets in question (paragraph lo)contained signatures with the SEune constructive characteristics of one signer. The likeness in construction of the letters is most apparent in the first 5 lines of sheet 34(See Attached) and the Izist 6 signatures of sheet 126 (See Attached). In both sheets there are 5-6 signatures, all aligned and stacked one below the other with the same writing features and characteristics. The other 5 sheets,itemized in Objector's Petition also contain very similar signatures, appearing to be of one writer. These signatures found to be forged by the expert witness; were sworn to by Mr. Hobby as valid and having been witnessed by him; and sworn to by him; unequivocally demonstrate clear and con\incing evidence of Hobby's pattern offraud and false swearing. No reasonable person viewing the signatures while listening to Mr. Spencer, could escape the conclusion that they were not signed by those individual voters. The circulator assumes the duty and task of gathering and witnessing signatures on the petition sheets of qualified registered voters. In addition, he/she must sign the petition sheet containing, in part, the following language:
"...circulator statement signed by a person 18 years ofage or older who is a citizen ofthe United States, stating the street address... the county, city, village or town,and state; and certifying that the signatures on that sheet ofthe petition were signed in his or her presence and certifying that the signatures are genuine; and either(1)indicating the dates on which that sheet was circulated, or(2)indicating the first and last dates on which the sheet was circulated,or(3)for elections where the petition circulation period is 90 days,certifying that none ofthe signatures on the sheet were signed more than 90 days preceding the last day for the filing ofthe petition, or(4)for the 2022 general primary election only, certify that the signatures on the sheet were signed during the period of January 13,2022 through March 14,2022 or certify that the signatures on the sheet were signed during the period ofJanuary 13,2022 through the date on which this Statement was sworn or affirmed to and certifying that to the best ofhis or her knowledge and beliefthe persons so signing were at the time ofsigning the petitions qualified voters ofthe political party for which a nomination is sought. Such statement shall be 23-EB-ALD-032 HO RECOMMENDATION. pdf - 01/03/2023 1:04 pm sworn to before some officer authorized to administer oaths in this State”. 10 ILCS 5/7-10 The letter of the statue provides that Mr. Kevin Hobby, was charged with collecting qualified voter signatures on petition sheets, and subsequently presenting these sheets before a notary attesting to: the fact they were signed in his presence and certifying that the signatures are genuine.
Page 10
In reviewing Mr. Hobby’s 7 petition sheets mentioned in paragraph 10 of Objector’s Petition plus sheet 126 found later, and in light of the uncontroverted evidence presented showing multiple signatures by the same hand, it is reasonable to conclude any one or all of the following: a) Mr. Hobby knew about the forged signaturcs; b) he witnessed the forged signatures; c) he did not actually circulate the petitions and did not witness the signatures; d) or participated in the procurement and production of the forged signatures. This conduct clearly amounts to a pattern of fraud and false swearing by Mr. Hobby. Section 7/10 of the Electin Code has been strictly enforced by the courts of this State, which have viewed the circulators’ oath as an important way to safeguard fair and honest elections.
The court rulings in such cases have decided to invalidate those sheets showing the pattern of fraud and false swearing. See Thomas L Fortas v. Patricia Dixon, 122 Il].App.3d 697 (1*t Dist. 1984) and Herbert Huskey v. Municipal Officers Electoral Board Village of Ouk Lawn, 156 Ill. App 3d 201 (1% Dist. 1987) and Smith v. Jennings, 99-EB-ALD-121, CBEC, January 28, 1999 A review by the Hearing Officer of the remaining 36 sheets circulated by Kevin Hobby did not have any signatures similar to the ones already described with the sheets in question. No other anomaly or irregulates were observed of those sheets and signatures, and as mentioned earlier, no evidenced was presented relating to these sheets. In this case, all of the following sheets contained 10 signatures: Sheet 23, 34, 119, 123, 126, 127, 128 and 129. These 8 sheets totaling 80 signatures are all found to be invalid because of Mr. Hobby’s pattern of fraud and false swearing. Subtracting 80 signatures from the Candidates total valid signatures of 540, leaves 460 signatures. He has 13 signatures less than the required 473.
Finally, it should be noted that the Hearing Officer found a discrepancy in sheet 111 of the Candidate’s nomination sheets. That sheet, while appearing in consecutive order of Candidate’s nomination sheets, contained the heading of “Ja’Mal Green for Mayor of the 23-EB-ALD-032 HO RECOMMENDATION.pdf - 01/03/2023 1:04 pm City of Chicago". It does not appear in the Record Examination Summar>'Report, and so it is not clear whether it was removed, not objected to, or some other fate. In any event, it does not impact the Candidate's signatures, as it would not have been counted regardless. No objections were raised about this issue and/or pagination issues, and so it will be deemed waived and of no consequence.
Page 11
CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATION
Credible and reliable witness testimony of signature forger>' was presented by the Objectors'forensic document examiner. These included 8 separate signature sheets, each containing lO signatures for total of 8o signatures, with many forged names. This evidence, together with the surrounding circumstances, the requirements of the Election Code and its interpretations by Courts supports a finding of a pattern offraud and false swearing by circulator Ke\in Hobby. Therefore, those 8 sheets and all 8o signatures contained therein are found to be invalid. They are hereby subtracted from the Candidates 540 valid signatures, leaving a total of 460 valid signatures. The Candidate is then short 13 valid signatures from the minimum 473 signatures required by law. It is the Hearing Officer's recommendation that the name of Don Davis not be placed on the ballot for the February 28,2023 election for Alderperson of the Third (3'"<^) Ward, City of Chicago, State of Illinois.
Resp fully Submitted, E. Colon, Hearing Officer December 31,2022
Page 12
Attached attached petition: shown in the PDF at page 12.
Page 13
Attached attached petition: shown in the PDF at page 13.
Page 14
Attached attached petition: shown in the PDF at page 14.